North Yorkshire Council has approved a plan to convert The Pines care home on Harlow Moor Drive into 12 apartments.
The 28-bed care home was forced to close in 2016 following an inadequate rating by the regulator Care Quality Commission.
It sits in a prominent location opposite Valley Gardens and the Pinewoods in the town.
Plans by Ilkley-based developer Flatcap Properties LLP follow two refused bids to turn the building into flats.
However, in both cases, the council said the property had not been sufficiently marketed as a care home before the application was submitted.
This is a requirement when changing the use of a care home to prove that it is no longer viable.
This time, the building was put up for sale as a care home for 12 months without any takers.
A report said due to its configuration, the property would be refused a new CQC registration due to small room sizes.
In the approved plans, the apartments will be formed through a subdivision of the building. However, some external changes are proposed primarily to create individual entrances to a number of apartments.
Residents will be able to use free on-street parking on Harlow Moor Drive.
A planning statement attached to the application said:
“To conclude, we believe the proposals provide a high-quality and attractive scheme and represent a significant opportunity to secure the positive development of this redundant building, which will, in our view, enhance this site and the surrounding area as a whole.
“Overall, careful thought has been given to the design and layout of the proposed development and as such it is considered that the design of the proposal is appropriate, and it is our view that the new development will have a positive impact on this area of Harrogate.”

Children's boutique and art gallery opens in Knaresborough
Police issue update on body found in Ripon Canal
Retiring North Yorkshire Council chief executive gets pay package of almost £245,000
Harrogate Paralympian challenges controversial Sydney Sweeney sports advert
150 homes planned for green belt land near Harrogate
'Bonkers' burlesque show returns to Harrogate
North Yorkshire residents urged to recycle more household waste
Apple Throwing Championships return to Newby Hall
MPs urge Prime Minister to make A64 dualling a priority
Police appeal after radiator stolen from Ripon property
Ukrainian city thanks Knaresborough residents for ongoing humanitarian aid
New venue revealed for Harrogate vintage car meet
Body of man in his 60's discovered in Ripon canal
Harrogate MP vows to keep fighting for end-of-life choice
Holiday park expansion planned to meet need for more spacious pitches
Storm overflow investigation to begin on Stray in Harrogate
Ferrari worth more than £2 million spotted in Harrogate
Historic Ripon buildings open their doors for Heritage Open Days
Martin House doctor shares realities of children's palliative care in new book
Work gets underway on new Gail's Bakery in Harrogate


